Work-from-home mom explicitly bans loud toys as birthday gifts, sister-in-law shows up with a drum kit and a police siren anyway, so she throws the toys out: 'Ignoring my boundaries isn't a gift, it's a power move'

• 01
  
  via charlesdeluvio

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• "AITA for returning my SILs "thoughtful" gifts for my kids because she ignored my one simple rule?"

  "I (32F) have two kids (4 and 6). I also work from home in a job that requires a lot of focus and frequent client calls. My sister in law "Sarah" has always been the "cool aunt" type who thinks rules are just suggestions.

  Last month , I explicitly told the entire extended family in our group chat that for the kids birthdays , please do not buy anything that makes loud electronic noise. No sirens , no singing dolls , no drum kits. I explained that I am struggling to keep my home office professional and the kids already have plenty of noisy stuff."

  -PixelBanshee_4 

• 02
  
  via Rhamely

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• Setting boundaries with extended family is already a full-time job. But when you work from home, have two small kids, and need your house to function as a professional environment, "please don't buy loud electronic toys" is not an unreasonable ask. It is, in fact, one of the most reasonable requests a person can make. It was communicated clearly, in writing, in a group chat, with context and explanation. Sarah even responded with a thumbs up.

  And then she showed up with a drum pad and a police siren loud enough to alert an actual neighborhood emergency.

• 03
  
  via Getty Images

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• "Sarah replied with a "thumbs up" emoji so I thought we were good. Fast forward to the joint birthday party last weekend. Sarah shows up with two massive boxes. 

  The kids open them and it is a high-tech electronic drum pad and a "super mega police station" with a siren that is honestly louder than a real one. The kids obviously went feral with joy. I caught Sarahs eye and she just winked and said 'kids need to express themselves , don't be such a killjoy.' "

  -PixelBanshee_4 

• 04
  
  via Ahmet Kurt

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• The "kids need to express themselves" defense is a classic move from the playbook of people who want to be the fun one without having to deal with any of the consequences. Sarah does not live in that house. Sarah does not take the client calls. Sarah does not have to explain to a confused colleague why there is a siren going off in the background of a Zoom meeting. Sarah just gets to be the favorite aunt and then go home.

  Returning the toys was not cold. It was logical. If Sarah genuinely believes a drum kit is an appropriate gift for a four and six year old, she is welcome to host that particular form of self-expression at her own house. That is not punishment. That is just redirecting the chaos to its most enthusiastic supporter.

• 05
  
  via HiveBoxx

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• "I waited until the party was over and everyone left. I didnt make a scene in front of the kids. The next morning , while the kids were at school , I packed the toys back into their boxes and drove them straight to Sarahs house. I left them on her porch and sent her a text saying: 

  "Since you think these are such great gifts for kids to express themselves , they can stay at your house for when they visit you. They aren't coming into my home."

  -PixelBanshee_4 

   

• 06
  
  via Jan Baborák

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• The real issue here is not the toys. It is that Sarah looked at an explicit request, agreed to it, ignored it entirely, and then expected zero pushback. That is not a gift. That is a test. And this mom passed it.

  "Hide the batteries" is not a boundary. Returning the toys is.

• 07
  
  via Getty Images

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• "Now my MIL and Sarah are blowing up my phone. Sarah is crying saying I am "ungrateful" and that she spent a lot of money to be the favorite aunt. My MIL says I am "alienating" family over some plastic noise and that I should just "hide the batteries." I told them that ignoring my boundaries isnt a gift , it is a power move. My husband is on my side but thinks I was "unnecessarily cold" by dropping them on the porch without talking to her face to face.

  AITA here? I feel like if I let this slide , she will just keep doing whatever she wants because "it is for the kids." 

  -PixelBanshee_4

   

• 08
  
  via Getty Images

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• SignificanceHead9957

  “Also give the kids a whistle when they visit her.”

• SailingFire2020

  "NTA. She deliberately ignored the rules of the parents. You’re not fully returning the gift, just saying you won’t have them in your home. Sarah needs to accept that boundaries exist, and especially with parents you can’t overstep."

• Lvanwinkle18

  “NTA. You set boundaries. She ignored them. You reinforced your boundaries in a healthy way, not in front of your children. You can still be a cool aunt without ignoring what the parents have said.”

• mtcrick

  “NTA as I was reading I was thinking that I would have done exactly what you did.”

• That_Ol_Cat

  "Sarah dumped them at your house, it's only fair you dump them at hers. She's the "cool aunt" she can put up with some noise for her niblings, right?"

• Amazing-Wave4704

  "NTA. I accidentally did something on a much smaller scale. My sister was driving through with her two small kids and I got a thumb guitar and a little hand drum from a museum gift shop. I really thought (I was maybe 27) that I was getting them something fun and the kind of thing I always wanted and didn't get. My sister said THANKS for getting these for our 24 hour car ride!!!! I completely understood and never did it again.

  This was NOT an accident. She purposely ignored your one rule. They can pound sand."

• 09
  
  via Theo

  _{Image is representative only and does not depict the actual subjects of the story.}

• Ready-Conflict-1887

  "No I think you handled that like a boss, you didn’t even return return them just said keep them at your house. It’s an excellent switcharoo"

• Enough-Reindeer1033

  “NTA. It's all about boundaries. You asked nicely and she refused to honor that request. That's on her. She needs to be accountable for her decisions”

• Regular_Look_1962

  "I’m not a parent and have always understood you check noisy gifts with parents first, and if they say no then you get something else. You are NTAH"

Tags